I can't make sense of my 1 year anniversary idea!?

Great idea! Put the pictures in starting with the first place you went together, then second, third, and so forth. When you get to the end of the photos, then put a piece of photo weight card stock or nice stationary cut to photo size and write the very words you used above and add " with someone I really care about". Or if you don't really care about the girl, just say with you and add her name. Such as ,"Many more amazing memories to come with you, (here put her name). Happy Anniversary!